Like most people these days my reading habits are best described as scanning, occasionally slowing down and paying attention when something grabs me. As I was reading the foreword to Issue 122 of Selvedge Magazine this stopped me in my tracks:
“According to the United Nations Environment Programme, textile dye is the second largest global water polluter and the Fashion Industry’s biggest offender.”
Suddenly I began looking at my clothes, household textiles, and the yarns that I work with in a different way, with judgement and suspicion.
I already consider myself a fairly ‘conscious’ buyer – not militant, but certainly careful in my choices, however, my decisions are generally about fibre content and provenance – rarely about the dye processes involved.
So I’ve been thinking more about this and actively seeking out collections of yarn that are either the colours nature intended, or that are coloured using natural dyes, and I was delighted to discover Burnt Fen Alpacas at the East Anglian Yarn Festival this Spring.
Burnt Fen Alpacas is just a few miles from me in Horning, Norfolk in the UK; it’s home to over 40 Alpacas who provide the fibre for the beautiful 100% alpaca yarn which is sold in the shop – and it’s also used for dying in their natural dye workshops. There was a selection of their naturally dyed alpaca yarns on display at the festival and there’s something about the quality of these colours that’s so different to those achieved with acid dyes. They’re quiet, understated, utterly beautiful…..and kind.
I find the subject of natural dyeing fascinating but also a little strange and mysterious, it’s like mixing a magic potion. Unlike modern acid and direct dyes they seem to hold a strange alchemy requiring specialist knowledge that can only be gained through years of practice and experimentation.
I always imagined natural dye techniques would entail long walks in the country gathering baskets full of seasonal flowers, berries and other native dye materials, followed by careful weighing and preparation of strange archaic substances, then hours of stirring a cauldron watching the dyestuff perform its magic.
Why would anyone in the 21st century even want to boil up handfuls of grubby vegetables just to dye a few grams of wool a rather ugly shade of beige?
I guess the answer is – the magnetic and irresistible power of curiosity. It’s that voice in your head that begins every sentence with;
“I wonder what would happen if….”
And ends it with;
”No, I can’t package it, sell it, affiliate market it or drop ship it. I just want to do it!”
The years I spent teaching textiles in different educational environments were filled with opportunities to try new things and investigate different materials techniques and processes. So as someone prone to curiosity a few years ago I rather recklessly announced to one of my Steiner Handwork classes that we’d be doing a natural dye project – and no, I’d never done natural dying before.
So here’s a little insight into how it’s possible to create a palette of the most beautiful coloured yarn equipped with kitchen utensils, some foraged materials and a few inquisitive minds.
We worked with plant materials that were easy to find. Some came from our gardens, and kitchens; some came from the supermarket, and the woad we used was bought online. But none of it was difficult to find.
We had no recipe book, just a vague idea of what we thought might happen.
I should probably also say that, for me, one of the joys of this project was the delight of discovery and the freedom of exploration. The colours achieved are non-repeatable, I can’t predict how colour fast they’ll be and I can’t really explain the chemistry involved.
I can, however, tell you that the process was intriguing, the colours were beautiful and the stories we uncovered about the history of natural dyes were surprising and compelling.
For me the subject of textiles has always been the subject of everything; history, geography, science, art – textiles can be used as a vehicle for navigating a route through all of these things, and the history of natural dyes has much to tell us about….well, pretty much everything.
So this is what we did – and what we learnt along the way.
- MORDANTING
We started with around 500gms of undyed aran weight woollen yarn which we wound into small skeins of about 10gms each.
We washed the skeins in warm soapy water and rinsed them well.
We used Alum (which we bought online) and cream of tartar (which we bought in the supermarket) to mordant the wool. Mordanting ensures the dye fixes to the fibres.
We allowed 1tsp of allum and 1tsp of cream of tartar for every 100gms of yarn.
Remember, this is my ‘suck it and see’ recipe!
Because we only had large kitchen saucepans to work with we decided to split up into 4 groups at this point. Each group dissolved 3-4 teaspoons of alum, and cream of tartar in a cup of hot water then added this to a pan containing enough water to cover the skeins and stirred well to make sure everything was completely dissolved.
Then we added the wet wool to the pan – each group added 12 or 13 of the tiny skeins. We brought this to simmering and continued to simmer for about an hour. Then we turned off the heat and left it overnight.
The next day we were ready to dye. We didn’t rinse the mordanted skeins……and what was left of the mordant bath was disposed of in the sink with lots of running water
- PH LEVELS AND A LITTLE BIT OF SCIENCE
The PH level of the dye bath affects the colour of the dye so we experimented with adjusting these levels using vinegar and citric acid to make the dyes more acidic, and washing soda to make the dyes more alkaline. We used litmus papers to test the PH levels and found that generally 1 or 2 teaspoons was enough to significantly change the PH level – but also, too much of either additive had a detrimental effect on the handle of the wool.
For each plant material that we used we made up a neutral dyebath, an acidic bath and an alkaline bath; aiming to achieve three different colour variations from one natural dye source.
- MAKING THE VEGETABLE DYE BATHS
We were very kindly donated a huge bag of yellow onion skins and we used these to make our first dyes as I’d read that this is the easiest plant material to work with and usually gives excellent results.
Working in 3 groups we each filled a pan about one third full of onion skins (no weighing or measuring for us!) filled it about two thirds full of cold water and heated it to boiling point.
We added citric acid to one pan and washing soda to another – the third remained neutral then we let these simmer for about an hour before taking it off the heat and leaving it overnight.
The next day the dye baths were strained and sieved to remove the plant material.
This is pretty much what we did to prepare all the natural dyebaths – we just filled the pans one third full with plant material – chopped up if we thought it was necessary.
Relying on kind donations by teachers and parents, and whatever the students brought in with them that particular day, we experimented with a good range of plant and vegetable dyes including;
Yellow onion skin, elderberry, blackberry, sloeberry, plum, red cabbage, horsetail, dahlia.
- DYEING THE WOOL
We added 2 or 3 skeins of wet mordanted wool to each dye bath and brought the temperature up to boiling then allowed the dye bath to simmer for around 40 minutes, gently stirring occasionally, then took it off the heat and left it overnight.
The next day the skeins were removed from the dye baths and rinsed thoroughly. (you could wash the wool at this stage -but we didn’t)
This was the most exciting bit; examining the final results. Did they measure up to our expectations? Were they disappointing? Were they surprising? Did we like the colour? How did the dye bath effect the handle of the wool?
We came to the conclusion that the acidic dye baths yielded pinker/redder tones and the alkaline dye baths inched towards green.
We also discovered that if you secretly tip about 10 teaspoons of washing soda into a dye bath when instructed to add just one the result is a nasty weak and scratchy yarn…..
There was also a spin off group conducting their own secret dye ‘experiments’ using old teabags, biro pens, the left over contents of their lunch boxes and some apple peel from the bin. The results of these tests were disappointing.
So that’s it really – we did this with all the plant materials we collected and (mostly) achieved a beautiful collection of colours. Some were surprising; the dahlia flowers produced the most vibrant shade of yellow – a lovely brilliant sunshiny colour. The red cabbage yielded a pretty pink, a lilac and a sage green and the berries all gave up subtle variations on beige and pinky brown
DYEING WITH WOAD
I decided to buy in the woad as I was keen for everyone to experience the magical oxidising process – where the materials change from murky yellow to brilliant blue as they make contact with the oxygen in the air – and I didn’t want to disappoint by using a less ‘tried and tested’ source of woad. I bought ours from here it came with excellent instructions on how to use it and it didn’t disappoint! It was easy to use and really did produce the most intense indigo blues that added a depth and richness to our natural dye colour palette.
THE COLOUR STORIES
Throughout the dye process we also learnt about how the history of natural dyes illuminates our history books with stories that date back to Greek legend and span the breadth of the globe.
We learnt why purple, historically, was such a coveted colour. None of our experiments produced strong purple shades and throughout history this was the most difficult colour to achieve.
For centuries, until the discovery of the first synthetic dye; mauve, or aniline purple, the mucus of a particular Mediterranean sea snail yielded the best bright and colour fast purple dye. But it took 10 000 snails to yield just 1 gram of dyestuff and it was so expensive only the very rich and powerful could afford to wear it. We imagined Cleopatra’s ships with their brilliant purple sails billowing in the wind, and Julius Caesar returning to Rome wearing a vivid violet toga.
Throughout history purple has signified extreme wealth and power. It’s been such a provocative colour that wearing it could even be viewed as high treason with the penalty of death.
We learnt that in Britain, before the introduction of synthetic dyes, our 3 staple dyestuffs were Weld (yellow) Woad (blue) and Madder (red) and these three colours were mixed and over-dyed to create a whole spectrum of colours.
Weld is said to produce the most brilliant yellow – and when over-dyed with woad it creates the brightest forest green; the green apparently worn by Robin Hood and his Merry Men. This colour was known as Lincoln Green and it’s been immortalised through hundreds of story books and films over the years.
We learnt about woad; our native ‘indigo’ dye which was used by Ancient Britons not only to dye textiles, but to dye whole bodies in preparation for war with the invading Romans. We imagined the fear and confusion created by an army of blue Celtic Iceni led by Boudica, a passionate female warrior with flaming red hair. We also discovered that the Celts knew a bit about medicine too as woad has natural astringent properties so it served two purposes as they marched into battle.
Madder was the dye we didn’t get to try so we are missing a good red from our colour palette. But we did lean that, strictly speaking, the colour yielded by madder is more orange than a true red but the concept – and consequently the word – orange didn’t exist in Britain until the introduction of oranges (the fruit) in the late 15th century. So it seems that a colour can’t exist in our consciousness until it’s been named.
THE COLLABORATIVE CROCHET PROJECT
So, after several days of dyeing, and story telling, we had a collection of unique, unrepeatable, extremely beautiful coloured yarns to work with and we started to make our granny squares. I’d already decided that a crochet blanket would be the perfect way to use all those small skeins of coloured yarn.
I love collaborative projects. I love that everyone, whatever their skills or experience is able to contribute what they can. Every small piece represents an individual and the finished work represents the group.
So some of the ‘squares’ were less than square and required a little ‘help’ to straighten then up. Some were very large, some were a little holey and some were perfectly executed but they were all inherently charming and I took them home over the Christmas break to finish piecing them together.
And here’s the finished blanket after blocking and pressing, with a small amount of bought in aran yarn – and I absolutely adore it.
At first glance it looks like any other conventional, slightly wobbly crochet granny square blanket, but it’s so much more than that. It’s a visual reminder that we learn through collaboration, practical experience, experimentation and imaginative story telling.
The blanket is a window into the past reminding us of the colours our ancestors experienced and it’s also evidence that it’s possible to create beautiful craft objects by working with, not against, nature.
For further reading on the impact of Textile Dyes on Water:
https://www.fashionrevolution.org/water-first-fashion-second/
https://healtheplanet.com/100-ways-to-heal-the-planet/textile-dyeing
https://goodonyou.eco/textile-dyes-pollution/
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c870j92p82wo
I’ve used natural dyes a few times. The thing that I love about them, is that no matter which colours you put next to each other, they always look beautiful. The colours last well too. I have things made years ago which still look lovely. The strange thing is, that I often find it difficult to describe one of these colours exactly! I would say that no matter which colour one is looking at, all are somehow ‘gentle.’ Even a bright colour is still, to me anyway, ‘gentle.’
Yes – that’s very true and what a good way to explain it!
Wow thank you for such an enlightening Blog, I to never realised what an impact all this acid dying is doing to the enviroment and will definately be far more mindfull when it comes to buying yarn in the future.
You’re welcome, I’m glad you found the blog post interesting.
the solution for the great pollution of dyes is a cleaner process and not going back to natural dyes. natural dyes are expensive (not of course for the individual dyer who can resource plantmaterial in his environment – like I do) when it has to be produced in a larger scale. it also takes agricultural land that otherwise is used for food. you tell a beautifull story about dying with woad, but think also about the big conflicts about indigo in colonial times in India. if the big capitalist companies have to work with natural dyes it will not longer be a nice story. (as it is now in part with the production of bio-cotton).
this is not a black and white story, I will never pretend that I know how it should be or not be. I am a natural dyer, but I know very well that this can not be a rule for a whole population. and also we should be aware that natural dyed wool should not be for only the happy few.
we live in a difficult world. thank you for posting your thoughts about dying and the fashion-industry. it should be a concern for everybody.
Hi Mieke, thank you for taking the time to read and comment on this post. I totally agree that any attempt to use natural dyes on an industrial scale is both impractical and comes with it’s own environmental, social and political issues. I’m definitely not suggesting this would be a solution to the massive problem of pollutants created by the fashion and textile industry and wouldn’t want to pretend that this is an answer. But I’d like to think that the choices we, as both crafters and consumers, make can influence trends. So any discussion around this subject is to be encouraged – thank you for joining the conversation! Best wishes, Sue